I also would like to select 'optimize for performance' but when I do, it is very hard to stop the drive and eject, to unplug it. Almost always I get the message to 'try later because the drive cannot be stopped'. This goes on for hours, and I am reluctant to leave the HDD connected when I am not using it because it has all my backups. I am worried about corrupting or garbling my backups inadvertently. I will certainly choose 'optimize for performance' if there is some way to unplug the drive when I am no longer using it.